CRAYON
Every story · every side  ·  est. 1995
U.S.

Susan Smith seeks parole again 32 years after drowning her two sons

Photo: BBC World
CRAYON summary

Susan Smith, convicted of killing her two sons, both under age four, by rolling her car into a South Carolina lake in 1994, was denied parole at her second hearing, 32 years after the killings. Her first parole request, in 2024, was unanimously denied.

Written by CRAYON from the outlets' reports below.
How the coverage differs

The main difference is timing: ABC News reports the outcome, saying Smith "was denied parole again," while Newsweek and BBC World describe a hearing that is still upcoming or in progress. Newsweek frames its piece as an explainer of the case and gives background on the process, noting her first parole bid in 2024 was "unanimously denied." BBC World focuses on the victims, noting both boys were under four. ABC News gives the most detail about the crime itself, describing how Smith rolled her car into a South Carolina lake in 1994.

CRAYON analysis of the outlets' accounts — read them below and judge for yourself.
▲ Sign in to vote stories up

Coverage 4 sources · 5 reports · 2L2C

Chronological — read the same story from every side and decide for yourself.

  1. Newsweek FIRST 27h ago Susan Smith Case Explained: Mother Who Drowned Children Faces Parole Hearing

    Susan Smith faces her second parole hearing this week, after her first appeal in 2024 was unanimously denied.

  2. BBC World 4h ago Susan Smith seeks parole again 32 years after drowning her two sons

    This is the second time Smith has requested to be released from prison for killing the two boys, who were both under the age of four at the time.

  3. Newsweek 3h ago Susan Smith Denied Parole Decades After Drowning Murders of 2 Young Sons

    Susan Smith was denied parole again 32 years after murdering her two young sons in South Carolina.

  4. ABC News 2h ago Susan Smith denied parole again 32 years after drowning sons in a South Carolina lake

    Susan Smith, convicted of killing her two sons by rolling her car into a South Carolina lake in 1994, was denied parole again

  5. The Washington Post 1h ago Susan Smith denied parole 32 years after drowning sons in S.C. lake

    The boys’ father, David Smith, said it would be “an injustice” to set her free in his plea for her to remain behind bars.

Discussion 0 comments